Found a new website today, courtesy of Raging Rouge. They're having a March Madness sale - 20% off everything. It looks like they have a wide variety of products, although I haven't taken the time to do a full scale investigation. I see they do offer the NYX line, which is amazing eye shadow. They make an orange that is sweet sweet bliss to any Vols fan!
I have noticed that the prices range from the disgustingly cheap (eye shadow for $1!!!) to the relatively expensive, so fun could truly be had with the 20% off.
Enjoy, and let me know if you find something I need!